Pet cemeteryPrivate cremationIndividual cremationCommunal cremationCrematory on site, says their websiteBurial, says their website

Final Gift - Regency Forest Pet Memorial

Pet cemetery in Middle Island, New York.

4.0from 226 ratings on its business listing
Listing claimed by the owner
Ashes back in about 4 daysTypical in 17 reviews that say how long
105 pet owners mention compassion with the familyReviews on its listing · latest 2026
18 checks answered on their websiteRead 21 Nov 2026
Call (631) 345-0600 Directions finalgift.com
5 mi10 mi15 miFGNSFPTPLPMBP
760 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY 11953
Letters match the nearby list below
Two cupped hands holding a sleeping kitten

If your pet has just passed, there is no rush

First steps for tonight, and who near Middle Island, NY says on its website that it answers after hours

What to do in the first hours

What pet owners say

192 reviews about pet aftercare on the Final Gift - Regency Forest Pet Memorial listing · each read and counted by topic · latest 10 Oct 2026

6 of 29 topics first · furthest from typical in New York
How a problem was handled
4 pet owners · 13 concerns · latest 2025
Concerns more often than typical in New York
Did what it said
4 pet owners · 16 concerns · latest 2026
Concerns more often than typical in New York
Kept them informed
11 pet owners · 20 concerns · latest 2026
Concerns more often than typical in New York
Paw print
20 pet owners · 9 concerns · latest 2025
Concerns more often than typical in New York
Handoff from the vet
5 pet owners · 6 concerns · latest 2024
Concerns more often than typical in New York
Urn quality
26 pet owners · 8 concerns · latest 2026
Concerns more often than typical in New York
See all 29 topics
Compassion with the family
105 pet owners · 5 concerns · latest 2026
Staff conduct
51 pet owners · 13 concerns · latest 2026
Pet handled with dignity
55 pet owners · 5 concerns · latest 2026
Facility
31 pet owners · 3 concerns · latest 2026
Time to say goodbye
27 pet owners · 4 concerns · latest 2026
Easy to arrange
28 pet owners · 2 concerns · latest 2026
Speed of return
22 pet owners · 7 concerns · latest 2026
Keepsakes (fur, certificate, card)
16 pet owners · 2 concerns · latest 2026
Cemetery upkeep
14 pet owners · 4 concerns · latest 2026
Sure the ashes were their pet's
9 pet owners · 6 concerns · latest 2025
Price felt fair
6 pet owners · 9 concerns · latest 2026
Explained options without pressure
13 pet owners · 2 concerns · latest 2026
Witnessed the cremation
10 pet owners · 1 concern · latest 2023
Home pickup
7 pet owners · 2 concerns · latest 2025
Same or next day
7 pet owners · latest 2026
Grief support
6 pet owners · latest 2025
Private really was private
3 pet owners · 3 concerns · latest 2021
Charged what was quoted
1 pet owner · 5 concerns · latest 2025
Ashes looked right
5 concerns, none positive · latest 2022
Home delivery of ashes
2 pet owners · 3 concerns · latest 2021
Burial service
3 pet owners · 1 concern · latest 2025
Remains lost or missing
4 concerns, none positive · latest 2021
Helped after hours
3 pet owners · latest 2022

In their own reviews, about Final Gift - Regency Forest Pet Memorial

Points pet owners raise

  • Some pet owners mention that cremation prices had doubled under new ownership compared with their earlier visits (2024)
  • Some pet owners mention that a private office previously used for cremation arrangements was no longer offered, and they were asked to stand at the front counter instead (2026)

Problems pet owners describe

  • Pet owners mention that their pets were cremated before a scheduled viewing, including one case the business reportedly described as a mistake (2, latest 2025)

People Final Gift - Regency Forest Pet Memorial lists on its website

April · named in 2 reviews

Only names their own website lists · count = reviews that mention each

Animals named in reviews of Final Gift - Regency Forest Pet Memorial
dogs 86 · cats 30 · small mammals 4 · birds 2 · rabbits 1 · horses 1

Before you call

What the website and reviews leave open

  • Who answers at night or on a weekendnothing on their site
Call (631) 345-0600

Prices

What Final Gift - Regency Forest Pet Memorial says about prices
Cremation costs are available by calling; the amount varies by pet weight and service.Their website: faqs

What Final Gift - Regency Forest Pet Memorial says it does

18 of our checks answered on the Final Gift - Regency Forest Pet Memorial website, each with its page

23 facts shared by every finalgift.com listing · 12 locations, one page

Public records

Air permit
EPA air-quality records list a permitted facility at this address: Final Gift USA LLC, status operating, record NY0000001472200112Source: EPA ECHO (ICIS-Air), Nov 2026

16 reviews mention an amount paid · never shown as its price

Other care near Final Gift - Regency Forest Pet Memorial

6 listings within 15 miles of Final Gift - Regency Forest Pet Memorial, nearest first, straight-line distance

All pet aftercare in Middle Island