Pet funeral service

Legacy Pet Crematory

Pet funeral service in West Babylon, New York.

5.0from 1,111 ratings on its business listing
Listing claimed by the owner
Ashes back in about 2 daysTypical in 66 reviews that say how long
849 pet owners mention compassion with the familyReviews on its listing · latest 2026
Call (516) 500-7387 Directions legacypetcrematory.com
5 mi10 mi15 miLPPCTPLILPWPBP
21 Eads St, West Babylon, NY 11704
Letters match the nearby list below
Two cupped hands holding a sleeping kitten

If your pet has just passed, there is no rush

First steps for tonight, and who near West Babylon, NY says on its website that it answers after hours

What to do in the first hours

What pet owners say

984 reviews about pet aftercare on the Legacy Pet Crematory listing · each read and counted by topic · latest 18 Oct 2026

6 of 28 topics first · furthest from typical in West Babylon
Helped after hours
43 pet owners · 3 concerns · latest 2026
Concerns more often than typical in West Babylon
Home delivery of ashes
3 pet owners · latest 2026
Praised more often than typical in West Babylon
Handoff from the vet
3 pet owners · 1 concern · latest 2026
Praised more often than typical in West Babylon
Cemetery upkeep
2 pet owners · latest 2025
Praised more often than typical in West Babylon
Compassion with the family
849 pet owners · 2 concerns · latest 2026
Concerns more often than typical in West Babylon
Paw print
27 pet owners · 2 concerns · latest 2026
Concerns more often than typical in West Babylon
See all 28 topics
Staff conduct
314 pet owners · 2 concerns · latest 2026
Pet handled with dignity
304 pet owners · latest 2026
Easy to arrange
236 pet owners · 1 concern · latest 2026
Facility
175 pet owners · latest 2026
Speed of return
126 pet owners · latest 2026
Explained options without pressure
100 pet owners · 1 concern · latest 2026
Price felt fair
96 pet owners · 4 concerns · latest 2026
Kept them informed
92 pet owners · 4 concerns · latest 2026
Urn quality
88 pet owners · latest 2026
Keepsakes (fur, certificate, card)
81 pet owners · 1 concern · latest 2026
Time to say goodbye
69 pet owners · 1 concern · latest 2026
Home pickup
66 pet owners · latest 2026
Did what it said
27 pet owners · 4 concerns · latest 2026
Sure the ashes were their pet's
25 pet owners · 1 concern · latest 2026
Grief support
20 pet owners · latest 2026
Witnessed the cremation
14 pet owners · 1 concern · latest 2026
Private really was private
13 pet owners · 1 concern · latest 2026
Ashes looked right
9 pet owners · latest 2025
Same or next day
9 pet owners · latest 2026
Charged what was quoted
7 pet owners · 1 concern · latest 2026
How a problem was handled
1 pet owner · 1 concern · latest 2026
Burial service
1 pet owner · latest 2025

In their own reviews, about Legacy Pet Crematory

Points pet owners raise

  • Pet owners mention services for small and less common pets, including guinea pigs, rats, hamsters, ferrets, rabbits, birds, and a duck (10, latest 2026)
  • Pet owners mention an online portal or tracking feature; others mention text or email updates (8, latest 2026)
  • Pet owners mention that staff gave instructions for keeping a pet overnight before bringing them in (2, latest 2026)

Problems pet owners describe

  • Pet owners mention that 24/7 availability covers calls or pickup, but the office may be closed to walk-ins; several say online hours suggesting 24-hour access caused confusion (6, latest 2026)
  • Some pet owners mention that after asking for all memorial-item options, they learned at pickup that some had not been mentioned and could no longer be added (2025)
Animals named in reviews of Legacy Pet Crematory
dogs 220 · cats 100 · small mammals 14 · reptiles 7 · birds 7 · rabbits 7

Before you call

What the website and reviews leave open

  • Whether your pet is cremated alonecremation types not set out on their site
  • Where the cremation is donenot stated on their site
  • Pickup from home or your vet, and the feenot described on their site · 66 pet owners mention a home pickup
  • When the ashes come backno time on their site · about 2 days in 66 reviews that say
  • Who answers at night or on a weekendnothing on their site
Call (516) 500-7387
What we could check
Nothing confirmed yet from legacypetcrematory.com

7 reviews mention an amount paid · never shown as its price

Other care near Legacy Pet Crematory

11 listings within 15 miles of Legacy Pet Crematory, nearest first, straight-line distance

All pet aftercare in West Babylon