Pet funeral servicePrivate CremationSemi-Private CremationCommunal CremationPickup, says their websiteAfter hours, says their website

Forever Remembered Pet Crematory

Pet funeral service in Eagle River, Wisconsin.

5.0from 21 ratings on its business listing
Listing claimed by the owner
Ashes back in about 1 daysTypical in 7 reviews that say how long
17 pet owners mention compassion with the familyReviews on its listing · latest 2026
2 published prices on their websiteEach with its page, below
Call (815) 482-9512 Directions foreverrememberedpetcrematory.com
5 mi10 mi15 miFR
591 Commerce Loop, Eagle River, WI 54521
No other provider within 15 miles in our data
Good to know before you call Forever Remembered Pet Crematory
  • The Google listing warns that the Eagle River address is a remote location with no staff on site and says to call before arrival.Their website: listing
  • The website requires appointments and says services are provided by appointment only during its listed normal business hours: Monday-Friday 8:30 a.m.-3:30 p.m.; Saturday 9 a.m.-12 noon; closed Sundays and holidays.Their website: contactus.html
Two cupped hands holding a sleeping kitten

If your pet has just passed, there is no rush

First steps for tonight, and who near Eagle River, WI says on its website that it answers after hours

What to do in the first hours

What pet owners say

20 reviews about pet aftercare on the Forever Remembered Pet Crematory listing · each read and counted by topic · latest 15 Oct 2026

6 of 17 topics first · furthest from typical in Wisconsin
Speed of return
10 pet owners · latest 2026
Praised more often than typical in Wisconsin
Pet handled with dignity
11 pet owners · latest 2026
Praised more often than typical in Wisconsin
Easy to arrange
6 pet owners · latest 2026
Praised more often than typical in Wisconsin
Explained options without pressure
4 pet owners · latest 2026
Praised more often than typical in Wisconsin
Helped after hours
2 pet owners · latest 2026
Praised more often than typical in Wisconsin
Price felt fair
3 pet owners · latest 2026
Praised more often than typical in Wisconsin
See all 17 topics
Compassion with the family
17 pet owners · latest 2026
Staff conduct
5 pet owners · latest 2026
Paw print
2 pet owners · latest 2026
Keepsakes (fur, certificate, card)
2 pet owners · latest 2026
Time to say goodbye
1 pet owner · latest 2025
Same or next day
1 pet owner · latest 2025
Ashes looked right
1 pet owner · latest 2026
Grief support
1 pet owner · latest 2025
Kept them informed
1 pet owner · latest 2025
Sure the ashes were their pet's
1 pet owner · latest 2025
Charged what was quoted
1 pet owner · latest 2026

In their own reviews, about Forever Remembered Pet Crematory

Points pet owners raise

  • Some pet owners mention that they could pick up their pet before paying because payday was later that week (2026)

People Forever Remembered Pet Crematory lists on its website

Jeff · named in 7 reviews

Only names their own website lists · count = reviews that mention each

Animals named in reviews of Forever Remembered Pet Crematory
dogs 6 · cats 1

Before you call

What the website and reviews leave open

  • Where the cremation is donenot stated on their site
  • When the ashes come backno time on their site · about 1 days in 7 reviews that say
Call (815) 482-9512

What Forever Remembered Pet Crematory says it does

15 of our checks answered on the Forever Remembered Pet Crematory website, each with its page

Services

Cremation types
Private: the pet is handled individually in the cremator; an engraved identification disc stays with the pet throughout.Their website: services.html
Semi-private: pets are separated by a partition, with no commingling of remains; ashes are returned.Their website: services.html · cremationfees.html
Communal: ashes are not returned to the family.Their website: cremationfees.html
Animals cared for
The site lists dogs, cats, other pets and exotic pets; its exotic-pet price entry covers 0-10 lbs.Their website: products.html · cremationfees.html

From pickup to coming home

Pickup
Pickup is available for an additional fee; call for pricing. The website does not specify pickup origin or area.Their website: cremationfees.html
After hours
The website lists a $50 after-hours fee for times outside normal posted hours, including weekends and holidays.Their website: contactus.html
Identification and tracking
For private cremation, an engraved stainless steel ID disc stays with the pet during cremation; the urn is labeled with the pet's name and cremation ID number. A certificate is prepared with the pet's name and cremation date.Their website: services.html
What is included
Private cremation includes a Rosewood Urn; semi-private includes a Decorative Tin Urn. Private and semi-private include a certificate and Rainbow Bridge poem; communal excludes both and returns no ashes.Their website: cremationfees.html
Urns and keepsakes
Urns and memorials include engraved rocks, garden stones, nameplates, paw-print and nose-print kits, and engraved dog tags.Their website: products.html · RockandGarden.html

About the business

What kind of business
Pet crematory.Their website: services.html
Who runs it
The site says the business is individually owned and operated; Jeff McGrath is the owner/operator. The Google listing says it was established in 2006.Their website: aboutus.html · listing
Memberships
Owner/operator Jeff McGrath says he has been certified by the crematory society since 2005; the society is not named.Their website: aboutus.html
Locations
The Google listing describes the business as having three locations and identifies the Eagle River location at 591 Commerce Loop.Their website: listing
Area served
Northern Wisconsin.Their website: foreverrememberedpetcrematory.com
Grief support
The site links to a pet-loss support website and a virtual memorial home.Their website: helpfullinks.html
Prices
Cremation prices are published on the fees page; pickup pricing requires a call.Their website: cremationfees.html
Pet aftercare
Yes. It offers private, semi-private and communal cremation services for pets.Their website: aboutus.html

Prices

2 prices as Forever Remembered Pet Crematory publishes them, with the page each is on

Their website · read 21 Nov 2026
ServiceForIncludes, as their site lists itPrice
Semi-private cremationPage: cremationfees.htmlExotic pets · 0-10 lbs.Rosewood Urn
Fees and conditions: Wisconsin sales tax: add 5.5% on all packages; pickup available for an additional fee, call for pricing.
$150
GeneralPage: cremationfees.htmlExotic pets · 0-10 lbs.Certificate of Cremation & Rainbow Bridge Poem
Fees and conditions: Wisconsin sales tax: add 5.5% on all packages; pickup available for an additional fee, call for pricing.
$50